POA Caselaw Evidence

Evidence

28 decisions in this topic.

Browne v Dunn

(1893) 6 R 67 · House of Lords · libel

Browne v. Dunn

(1893) 6 R 67
House of Lords | circa 1893


Background

This landmark 1893 House of Lords decision established one of the most fundamental rules of cross-examination that still governs courtrooms today. While …

Read the Decision

Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67

Read the Decision

Durham v Avernas [2007] Carswell Ont 8840

Read the Decision

Fleming v Toronto Railway

[1911] CarswellOnt 702 · Ontario Court of Appeal · negligence

Fleming v. Toronto Railway Company

1911 CarswellOnt 702, 20 O.W.R. 827
Ontario Court of Appeal — Hon. Mr. Justice Maclaren, Hon. Mr. Justice Meredith | December 30, 1911


Background

On August 10, 1910, Fleming was a …

Read the Decision

Heegsma v. Hamilton (City)

2026 ONCA 726 · Court of Appeal for Ontario

Summary

Fourteen appellants challenged Hamilton’s encampment restrictions under Charter ss. 7 and 15. ONCA found serious evidentiary and analytical errors, including reliance on stereotypes about mental illness and addiction. It allowed the appeal but made no Charter-breach finding, instead ordering …

Read the Decision

Paciocco & Stuesser

The Law of Evidence, 3rd ed. (2002)

Paciocco & Stuesser: The Law of Evidence, 3rd ed. (2002)

Chapter 10, Methods of Presenting Evidence - Section 5: Refreshing Memory
Legal textbook excerpt on memory refreshing rules


Background

This isn't a court case, but rather …

Read the Decision

Paciocco & Stuesser - The Law of Evidence

Chapter 10, Methods of Presenting Evidence (3rd ed. 2002) · Legal Textbook · General Evidence Rules

Refreshing Memory - Methods of Presenting Evidence

Chapter 10, Paciocco & Stuesser, The Law of Evidence (3rd ed. 2002)
Legal Textbook — D.M. Paciocco & L. Stuesser


Background

This chapter explains the legal framework for refreshing witness memory during testimony. …

Read the Decision

R. v. Alexis [1999] CarswellBC 2682 MVR (3d) 1, 181 DIR (4th) 719, 132 BCAC 270, 215, WAC 270, [1999] BCJ No 2666, 1999 BCCA 684

Read the Decision

R v Black

[2004] O.J. No. 6235 · Ontario Court of Justice · speeding

R. v. Black

[2004] O.J. No. 6235
Ontario Court of Justice — B.G. Thomas J. | December 1, 2004


Background

Michael Black was charged with speeding 134 km/h in a 100 km/h zone under section 128 …

Read the Decision

R v Boucher

2005 SCC 72 · Supreme Court of Canada · driving with blood alcohol over 80 mg

R. v. Boucher

[2005] SCC 72
Supreme Court of Canada — Deschamps J. (majority), Charron J. (dissenting) | December 2005


Background

Eric Boucher was driving home from a tavern in Montreal at 2:40 a.m. when he …

Read the Decision

R. v. Fitzpatrick

2026 ONCA 262 · Ontario Court of Appeal · First degree murder

R. v. Fitzpatrick

2026 ONCA 262
Ontario Court of Appeal — Rahman J.A. (Roberts and Pomerance JJ.A. concurring) | April 14, 2026


Background

On June 21, 2018, two men went to Brandon Hall's home and shot …

Read the Decision

R v Fliss

[2002] 1 SCR 535 · Supreme Court of Canada · first degree murder

R. v. Fliss

[2002] 1 S.C.R. 535, 2002 SCC 16
Supreme Court of Canada — Binnie J. (majority), Arbour J. (concurring) | February 21, 2002


Background

Peter William Fliss confessed to murdering Jo Anne Feddema during …

Read the Decision

R v Fourman

Unreported · Ontario Court of Justice · fail to stop at stop sign

R. v. Fourman

Court File No: 2860 999 00 3121712A
Ontario Court of Justice — Justice of the Peace George A. Griffith | May 18, 2010 (heard), June 22, 2011 (decision)


Background

On a snowy January …

Read the Decision

R v Germanis 2

Read the Decision

R v Hall [2013] ONSC 834

[2013] ONSC 834

Read the Decision

R v Khelawon 2006scc57

2006scc57

Read the Decision

R. v. McDonald

2025 ONCA 807 · Ontario Court of Appeal · second-degree murder

R. v. McDonald

2025 ONCA 807
Court of Appeal for Ontario — Fairburn A.C.J.O., Paciocco and Harvison Young JJ.A. | November 25, 2025


Background

William Dwayne McDonald was convicted of second-degree murder in the shooting death …

Read the Decision

R v Morrissey

[1995] OJ No 639 · Ontario Court of Appeal · sexual assault and assault causing bodily harm

Regina v. Morrissey

[1995] O.J. No. 639, 22 O.R. (3d) 514
Court of Appeal for Ontario — Osborne, Doherty and Laskin JJ.A. | March 14, 1995


Background

The appellant, a former Christian Brother who had become …

Read the Decision

R v Murphy

Unreported · Ontario Court of Justice · speeding

Her Majesty The Queen v. Patrick Murphy

Court File 81937428
Ontario Court of Justice — Justice D.C. Downie | December 16, 2004


Background

Patrick Murphy was pulled over on Highway 401 eastbound near the Homer Watson …

Read the Decision

R v Musleh

Unreported · Provincial Offences Court · speeding

R. v. Musleh

Provincial Offences Court, Toronto
Justice White — January 12, 1990


Background

Mohammed Musleh was charged with speeding 91 kilometres per hour in a 60 kilometre per hour zone on Lakeshore Boulevard West in …

Read the Decision

R v Odgers 2009 ONCJ 287

2009 ONCJ 287

Read the Decision

R v Oliver

[1993] O.J. No. 4464

Read the Decision

R v Persaud

[2011] O.J. No. 3312 · Ontario Court of Justice · speeding

R. v. Persaud

[2011] O.J. No. 3312
Ontario Court of Justice — M.F. Woolcott J. | January 13, 2011


Background

Danny Davindra Persaud was convicted of speeding contrary to section 128 of the Highway Traffic Act …

Read the Decision

R v Starr [2000] SCC 40

[2000] SCC 40

Read the Decision

R v Steele (trial)

Read the Decision

R v Villaroman [2016] 1 SCR 1001

Read the Decision

Facing a evidence issue?

Knowing the caselaw is half the fight — applying it to your facts is the other half. Free consultation, straight answers.

Licensed Paralegal — Not a Law Firm. Carli Geist is regulated by the Law Society of Ontario. Services are limited to the authorized scope of paralegal practice. Nothing on this site is legal advice.